City-Lifeline-Cockpit/.scratch/cockpit-shell-panel-layout/verify/artifacts/t35/large-building-audit/review.json

{
  "version": 1,
  "sourceAuditPlanSha256": "424dfd7208b15854854571c361947f6d59a95554305dda8f4f510dc75a857a16",
  "activeCoverageDefinition": "Seven roofed2 CAD manifests, matching audit-large-building-coverage.mjs; district and regular-estate survey/trace layers additionally checked for pilot overlap.",
  "method": "Offline local TMS z19, 7x7 tiles per view, 1792px cap; PNG or JPEG payload decoded from .png files. North-up XYZ rows read with TMS inverted Y. Actual saved images visually reviewed with read_image; no generated/invented satellite imagery.",
  "imagery": {
    "directory": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3",
    "zoom": 19,
    "totalTiles": 343,
    "missingTiles": 0,
    "acquisitionDate": "unknown",
    "groundResolutionMApprox": 0.263,
    "windows": [
      {
        "name": "central-estate",
        "tiles": 49,
        "missingTiles": 0,
        "candidates": 28,
        "activeOutlines": 4,
        "labeledIds": [
          "cad-20562",
          "cad-20556",
          "cad-20308",
          "cad-20534",
          "cad-20301",
          "cad-20293",
          "cad-20346"
        ]
      },
      {
        "name": "east-dense-edge",
        "tiles": 49,
        "missingTiles": 0,
        "candidates": 7,
        "activeOutlines": 8,
        "labeledIds": [
          "cad-3544",
          "cad-27407"
        ]
      },
      {
        "name": "south-central-edge",
        "tiles": 49,
        "missingTiles": 0,
        "candidates": 16,
        "activeOutlines": 16,
        "labeledIds": [
          "cad-15200"
        ]
      },
      {
        "name": "southwest-edge",
        "tiles": 49,
        "missingTiles": 0,
        "candidates": 7,
        "activeOutlines": 4,
        "labeledIds": [
          "cad-14165",
          "cad-13681"
        ]
      },
      {
        "name": "giant-industrial",
        "tiles": 49,
        "missingTiles": 0,
        "candidates": 10,
        "activeOutlines": 33,
        "labeledIds": [
          "cad-4057",
          "cad-4058",
          "cad-4060"
        ]
      },
      {
        "name": "giant-irregular",
        "tiles": 49,
        "missingTiles": 0,
        "candidates": 20,
        "activeOutlines": 130,
        "labeledIds": [
          "cad-27730"
        ]
      },
      {
        "name": "western-estate",
        "tiles": 49,
        "missingTiles": 0,
        "candidates": 45,
        "activeOutlines": 12,
        "labeledIds": [
          "cad-11179",
          "cad-11204",
          "cad-11154",
          "cad-11167",
          "cad-11192",
          "cad-11395",
          "cad-11386"
        ]
      }
    ]
  },
  "findings": "Confirmed dense residential omissions exist in safely seated rural-tier IDs. Top-area candidates are not interchangeable: real industrial halls and erroneous compound outlines both occur. Zero active overlap alone misses duplicates among nonactive candidates.",
  "pilot": {
    "primaryIds": [
      "cad-20556",
      "cad-20308",
      "cad-20534",
      "cad-20301",
      "cad-20293"
    ],
    "extendedIds": [
      "cad-20556",
      "cad-20308",
      "cad-20534",
      "cad-20301",
      "cad-20293",
      "cad-20562"
    ],
    "secondaryIds": [
      "cad-11179",
      "cad-11204",
      "cad-11154",
      "cad-11167",
      "cad-11192",
      "cad-11395",
      "cad-11386"
    ],
    "primaryRationale": "Five real roof-matched missing residential buildings, all already seated flat, all zero active/candidate/other-neighborhood overlap. Restore source outlines without changing global seating gates.",
    "extendedRationale": "cad-20562 adds a sixth confirmed housing slab but retains its existing near-cap bounded plinth.",
    "secondaryRationale": "Seven already-seated flat dense-estate slabs with matching gray ridged roofs; a second small batch, not all rural candidates."
  },
  "candidates": [
    {
      "id": "cad-20556",
      "locationWGS84": [
        110.39916867599997,
        28.446538756
      ],
      "areaSqm": 848.8,
      "dimensionsM": [
        63.76,
        14.85
      ],
      "sourceTier": "rural",
      "classification": "residential-slab",
      "decision": "recommend-pilot-flat",
      "roofMorphology": "Long gray roof bar in a dense riverside residential group; visible ridge/eave line, repeated small roof details and lane separations. The CAD edge follows the roof bar; cad-20308 has genuine stepped/notched outline, not a bounding rectangle.",
      "imageryMatched": true,
      "imageryReviewed": true,
      "evidence": [
        "central-estate-satellite.png",
        "central-estate-outlines.png",
        "central-estate-evidence.json"
      ],
      "auditStatus": "seated-outside-active-selection",
      "overlapActiveFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapId": null,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapFraction": 0,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapId": null,
      "seating": {
        "alreadySeated": true,
        "construction": "flat",
        "reliefM": 2.17,
        "terrainMinM": 111.95,
        "terrainMaxM": 114.12,
        "positionENU": [
          408.34,
          -826.91,
          113.87
        ],
        "estimatedHeightM": 19.2,
        "heightSource": "estimated-from-footprint-area"
      },
      "caveat": "Rural source tier is a mask/selection classification, not evidence of rural land use. Roof-to-ground parallax and undated imagery remain; floors/facades are estimates. Preserve current seated footprint and gray roof, not a generic blue warehouse roof.",
      "exclusionReason": null
    },
    {
      "id": "cad-20308",
      "locationWGS84": [
        110.39839411034484,
        28.446021065517243
      ],
      "areaSqm": 767.6,
      "dimensionsM": [
        16.99,
        64.41
      ],
      "sourceTier": "rural",
      "classification": "residential-slab",
      "decision": "recommend-pilot-flat",
      "roofMorphology": "Long gray roof bar in a dense riverside residential group; visible ridge/eave line, repeated small roof details and lane separations. The CAD edge follows the roof bar; cad-20308 has genuine stepped/notched outline, not a bounding rectangle.",
      "imageryMatched": true,
      "imageryReviewed": true,
      "evidence": [
        "central-estate-satellite.png",
        "central-estate-outlines.png",
        "central-estate-evidence.json"
      ],
      "auditStatus": "seated-outside-active-selection",
      "overlapActiveFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapId": null,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapFraction": 0,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapId": null,
      "seating": {
        "alreadySeated": true,
        "construction": "flat",
        "reliefM": 1.05,
        "terrainMinM": 113.43,
        "terrainMaxM": 114.48,
        "positionENU": [
          332.47,
          -884.29,
          114.23
        ],
        "estimatedHeightM": 16,
        "heightSource": "estimated-from-footprint-area"
      },
      "caveat": "Rural source tier is a mask/selection classification, not evidence of rural land use. Roof-to-ground parallax and undated imagery remain; floors/facades are estimates. Preserve current seated footprint and gray roof, not a generic blue warehouse roof.",
      "exclusionReason": null
    },
    {
      "id": "cad-20534",
      "locationWGS84": [
        110.3990957,
        28.445905325000002
      ],
      "areaSqm": 717.6,
      "dimensionsM": [
        59.14,
        12.13
      ],
      "sourceTier": "rural",
      "classification": "residential-slab",
      "decision": "recommend-pilot-flat",
      "roofMorphology": "Long gray roof bar in a dense riverside residential group; visible ridge/eave line, repeated small roof details and lane separations. The CAD edge follows the roof bar; cad-20308 has genuine stepped/notched outline, not a bounding rectangle.",
      "imageryMatched": true,
      "imageryReviewed": true,
      "evidence": [
        "central-estate-satellite.png",
        "central-estate-outlines.png",
        "central-estate-evidence.json"
      ],
      "auditStatus": "seated-outside-active-selection",
      "overlapActiveFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapId": null,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapFraction": 0,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapId": null,
      "seating": {
        "alreadySeated": true,
        "construction": "flat",
        "reliefM": 2.38,
        "terrainMinM": 112.37,
        "terrainMaxM": 114.75,
        "positionENU": [
          401.2,
          -897.12,
          114.5
        ],
        "estimatedHeightM": 16,
        "heightSource": "estimated-from-footprint-area"
      },
      "caveat": "Rural source tier is a mask/selection classification, not evidence of rural land use. Roof-to-ground parallax and undated imagery remain; floors/facades are estimates. Preserve current seated footprint and gray roof, not a generic blue warehouse roof.",
      "exclusionReason": null
    },
    {
      "id": "cad-20301",
      "locationWGS84": [
        110.39975156666667,
        28.44586014
      ],
      "areaSqm": 716.6,
      "dimensionsM": [
        59.14,
        12.17
      ],
      "sourceTier": "rural",
      "classification": "residential-slab",
      "decision": "recommend-pilot-flat",
      "roofMorphology": "Long gray roof bar in a dense riverside residential group; visible ridge/eave line, repeated small roof details and lane separations. The CAD edge follows the roof bar; cad-20308 has genuine stepped/notched outline, not a bounding rectangle.",
      "imageryMatched": true,
      "imageryReviewed": true,
      "evidence": [
        "central-estate-satellite.png",
        "central-estate-outlines.png",
        "central-estate-evidence.json"
      ],
      "auditStatus": "seated-outside-active-selection",
      "overlapActiveFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapId": null,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapFraction": 0,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapId": null,
      "seating": {
        "alreadySeated": true,
        "construction": "flat",
        "reliefM": 1.63,
        "terrainMinM": 111.72,
        "terrainMaxM": 113.35,
        "positionENU": [
          465.44,
          -902.12,
          113.1
        ],
        "estimatedHeightM": 16,
        "heightSource": "estimated-from-footprint-area"
      },
      "caveat": "Rural source tier is a mask/selection classification, not evidence of rural land use. Roof-to-ground parallax and undated imagery remain; floors/facades are estimates. Preserve current seated footprint and gray roof, not a generic blue warehouse roof.",
      "exclusionReason": null
    },
    {
      "id": "cad-20293",
      "locationWGS84": [
        110.39864197499999,
        28.446256699999992
      ],
      "areaSqm": 507.8,
      "dimensionsM": [
        44.68,
        11.54
      ],
      "sourceTier": "rural",
      "classification": "residential-slab",
      "decision": "recommend-pilot-flat",
      "roofMorphology": "Long gray roof bar in a dense riverside residential group; visible ridge/eave line, repeated small roof details and lane separations. The CAD edge follows the roof bar; cad-20308 has genuine stepped/notched outline, not a bounding rectangle.",
      "imageryMatched": true,
      "imageryReviewed": true,
      "evidence": [
        "central-estate-satellite.png",
        "central-estate-outlines.png",
        "central-estate-evidence.json"
      ],
      "auditStatus": "seated-outside-active-selection",
      "overlapActiveFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapId": null,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapFraction": 0,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapId": null,
      "seating": {
        "alreadySeated": true,
        "construction": "flat",
        "reliefM": 1.5,
        "terrainMinM": 111.78,
        "terrainMaxM": 113.27,
        "positionENU": [
          356.75,
          -858.17,
          113.02
        ],
        "estimatedHeightM": 16,
        "heightSource": "estimated-from-footprint-area"
      },
      "caveat": "Rural source tier is a mask/selection classification, not evidence of rural land use. Roof-to-ground parallax and undated imagery remain; floors/facades are estimates. Preserve current seated footprint and gray roof, not a generic blue warehouse roof.",
      "exclusionReason": null
    },
    {
      "id": "cad-20562",
      "locationWGS84": [
        110.39936334285717,
        28.446248600000008
      ],
      "areaSqm": 1023,
      "dimensionsM": [
        14.43,
        75.25
      ],
      "sourceTier": "rural",
      "classification": "residential-slab",
      "decision": "recommend-pilot-bounded-plinth",
      "roofMorphology": "Third long gray parallel residential roof south of the river road; outline follows a separate roof and stops before its active green neighbor.",
      "imageryMatched": true,
      "imageryReviewed": true,
      "evidence": [
        "central-estate-satellite.png",
        "central-estate-outlines.png",
        "central-estate-evidence.json"
      ],
      "auditStatus": "seated-outside-active-selection",
      "overlapActiveFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapId": null,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapFraction": 0,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapId": null,
      "seating": {
        "alreadySeated": true,
        "construction": "plinth",
        "reliefM": 3.18,
        "terrainMinM": 112.71,
        "terrainMaxM": 115.89,
        "positionENU": [
          427.41,
          -859.07,
          115.64
        ],
        "estimatedHeightM": 19.2,
        "heightSource": "estimated-from-footprint-area"
      },
      "caveat": "Already seated with 3.18m DEM relief, only 0.02m below the 3.2m relief cap. Keep the existing bounded plinth; do not widen/raise it. Prefer the five flat candidates for a stricter first export.",
      "exclusionReason": null
    },
    {
      "id": "cad-11179",
      "locationWGS84": [
        110.35718118055554,
        28.45946735833333
      ],
      "areaSqm": 778.5,
      "dimensionsM": [
        11.41,
        75.74
      ],
      "sourceTier": "rural",
      "classification": "residential-slab",
      "decision": "recommend-second-pilot-flat",
      "roofMorphology": "Repeated narrow gray pitched/ridged roof bars with light eave edges in a planned dense estate, arranged in parallel rows with real access lanes and a basketball court. Individual CAD outlines match individual roof bars and visible small edge notches.",
      "imageryMatched": true,
      "imageryReviewed": true,
      "evidence": [
        "western-estate-satellite.png",
        "western-estate-outlines.png",
        "western-estate-evidence.json"
      ],
      "auditStatus": "seated-outside-active-selection",
      "overlapActiveFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapId": null,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapFraction": 0,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapId": null,
      "seating": {
        "alreadySeated": true,
        "construction": "flat",
        "reliefM": 1.88,
        "terrainMinM": 132.9,
        "terrainMaxM": 134.78,
        "positionENU": [
          -3704.11,
          606.53,
          134.53
        ],
        "estimatedHeightM": 16,
        "heightSource": "estimated-from-footprint-area"
      },
      "caveat": "This is a substantial dense residential estate despite rural source tier; do not restore surrounding scattered houses wholesale. Repetition supports shared detail treatment, not invented identical measured heights. Small source roof features may be blurred.",
      "exclusionReason": null
    },
    {
      "id": "cad-11204",
      "locationWGS84": [
        110.35697099166666,
        28.459913291666666
      ],
      "areaSqm": 778.5,
      "dimensionsM": [
        75.75,
        11.38
      ],
      "sourceTier": "rural",
      "classification": "residential-slab",
      "decision": "recommend-second-pilot-flat",
      "roofMorphology": "Repeated narrow gray pitched/ridged roof bars with light eave edges in a planned dense estate, arranged in parallel rows with real access lanes and a basketball court. Individual CAD outlines match individual roof bars and visible small edge notches.",
      "imageryMatched": true,
      "imageryReviewed": true,
      "evidence": [
        "western-estate-satellite.png",
        "western-estate-outlines.png",
        "western-estate-evidence.json"
      ],
      "auditStatus": "seated-outside-active-selection",
      "overlapActiveFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapId": null,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapFraction": 0,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapId": null,
      "seating": {
        "alreadySeated": true,
        "construction": "flat",
        "reliefM": 2.31,
        "terrainMinM": 134.83,
        "terrainMaxM": 137.14,
        "positionENU": [
          -3724.68,
          655.95,
          136.89
        ],
        "estimatedHeightM": 16,
        "heightSource": "estimated-from-footprint-area"
      },
      "caveat": "This is a substantial dense residential estate despite rural source tier; do not restore surrounding scattered houses wholesale. Repetition supports shared detail treatment, not invented identical measured heights. Small source roof features may be blurred.",
      "exclusionReason": null
    },
    {
      "id": "cad-11154",
      "locationWGS84": [
        110.3573831138889,
        28.459021641666666
      ],
      "areaSqm": 778.4,
      "dimensionsM": [
        11.41,
        75.74
      ],
      "sourceTier": "rural",
      "classification": "residential-slab",
      "decision": "recommend-second-pilot-flat",
      "roofMorphology": "Repeated narrow gray pitched/ridged roof bars with light eave edges in a planned dense estate, arranged in parallel rows with real access lanes and a basketball court. Individual CAD outlines match individual roof bars and visible small edge notches.",
      "imageryMatched": true,
      "imageryReviewed": true,
      "evidence": [
        "western-estate-satellite.png",
        "western-estate-outlines.png",
        "western-estate-evidence.json"
      ],
      "auditStatus": "seated-outside-active-selection",
      "overlapActiveFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapId": null,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapFraction": 0,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapId": null,
      "seating": {
        "alreadySeated": true,
        "construction": "flat",
        "reliefM": 1.92,
        "terrainMinM": 134.13,
        "terrainMaxM": 136.05,
        "positionENU": [
          -3684.35,
          557.12,
          135.8
        ],
        "estimatedHeightM": 16,
        "heightSource": "estimated-from-footprint-area"
      },
      "caveat": "This is a substantial dense residential estate despite rural source tier; do not restore surrounding scattered houses wholesale. Repetition supports shared detail treatment, not invented identical measured heights. Small source roof features may be blurred.",
      "exclusionReason": null
    },
    {
      "id": "cad-11167",
      "locationWGS84": [
        110.35728191388888,
        28.45924443611111
      ],
      "areaSqm": 778.4,
      "dimensionsM": [
        11.41,
        75.74
      ],
      "sourceTier": "rural",
      "classification": "residential-slab",
      "decision": "recommend-second-pilot-flat",
      "roofMorphology": "Repeated narrow gray pitched/ridged roof bars with light eave edges in a planned dense estate, arranged in parallel rows with real access lanes and a basketball court. Individual CAD outlines match individual roof bars and visible small edge notches.",
      "imageryMatched": true,
      "imageryReviewed": true,
      "evidence": [
        "western-estate-satellite.png",
        "western-estate-outlines.png",
        "western-estate-evidence.json"
      ],
      "auditStatus": "seated-outside-active-selection",
      "overlapActiveFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapId": null,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapFraction": 0,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapId": null,
      "seating": {
        "alreadySeated": true,
        "construction": "flat",
        "reliefM": 2.36,
        "terrainMinM": 133.27,
        "terrainMaxM": 135.63,
        "positionENU": [
          -3694.25,
          581.82,
          135.38
        ],
        "estimatedHeightM": 16,
        "heightSource": "estimated-from-footprint-area"
      },
      "caveat": "This is a substantial dense residential estate despite rural source tier; do not restore surrounding scattered houses wholesale. Repetition supports shared detail treatment, not invented identical measured heights. Small source roof features may be blurred.",
      "exclusionReason": null
    },
    {
      "id": "cad-11192",
      "locationWGS84": [
        110.35707861388887,
        28.459691372222224
      ],
      "areaSqm": 778.4,
      "dimensionsM": [
        75.74,
        11.38
      ],
      "sourceTier": "rural",
      "classification": "residential-slab",
      "decision": "recommend-second-pilot-flat",
      "roofMorphology": "Repeated narrow gray pitched/ridged roof bars with light eave edges in a planned dense estate, arranged in parallel rows with real access lanes and a basketball court. Individual CAD outlines match individual roof bars and visible small edge notches.",
      "imageryMatched": true,
      "imageryReviewed": true,
      "evidence": [
        "western-estate-satellite.png",
        "western-estate-outlines.png",
        "western-estate-evidence.json"
      ],
      "auditStatus": "seated-outside-active-selection",
      "overlapActiveFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapId": null,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapFraction": 0,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapId": null,
      "seating": {
        "alreadySeated": true,
        "construction": "flat",
        "reliefM": 1.91,
        "terrainMinM": 133.47,
        "terrainMaxM": 135.38,
        "positionENU": [
          -3714.15,
          631.36,
          135.13
        ],
        "estimatedHeightM": 16,
        "heightSource": "estimated-from-footprint-area"
      },
      "caveat": "This is a substantial dense residential estate despite rural source tier; do not restore surrounding scattered houses wholesale. Repetition supports shared detail treatment, not invented identical measured heights. Small source roof features may be blurred.",
      "exclusionReason": null
    },
    {
      "id": "cad-11395",
      "locationWGS84": [
        110.35639027142858,
        28.4591883
      ],
      "areaSqm": 731.7,
      "dimensionsM": [
        11.54,
        67.67
      ],
      "sourceTier": "rural",
      "classification": "residential-slab",
      "decision": "recommend-second-pilot-flat",
      "roofMorphology": "Repeated narrow gray pitched/ridged roof bars with light eave edges in a planned dense estate, arranged in parallel rows with real access lanes and a basketball court. Individual CAD outlines match individual roof bars and visible small edge notches.",
      "imageryMatched": true,
      "imageryReviewed": true,
      "evidence": [
        "western-estate-satellite.png",
        "western-estate-outlines.png",
        "western-estate-evidence.json"
      ],
      "auditStatus": "seated-outside-active-selection",
      "overlapActiveFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapId": null,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapFraction": 0,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapId": null,
      "seating": {
        "alreadySeated": true,
        "construction": "flat",
        "reliefM": 1.6,
        "terrainMinM": 133.21,
        "terrainMaxM": 134.81,
        "positionENU": [
          -3781.58,
          575.62,
          134.56
        ],
        "estimatedHeightM": 16,
        "heightSource": "estimated-from-footprint-area"
      },
      "caveat": "This is a substantial dense residential estate despite rural source tier; do not restore surrounding scattered houses wholesale. Repetition supports shared detail treatment, not invented identical measured heights. Small source roof features may be blurred.",
      "exclusionReason": null
    },
    {
      "id": "cad-11386",
      "locationWGS84": [
        110.35628831428573,
        28.459411978571428
      ],
      "areaSqm": 731.5,
      "dimensionsM": [
        67.67,
        11.59
      ],
      "sourceTier": "rural",
      "classification": "residential-slab",
      "decision": "recommend-second-pilot-flat",
      "roofMorphology": "Repeated narrow gray pitched/ridged roof bars with light eave edges in a planned dense estate, arranged in parallel rows with real access lanes and a basketball court. Individual CAD outlines match individual roof bars and visible small edge notches.",
      "imageryMatched": true,
      "imageryReviewed": true,
      "evidence": [
        "western-estate-satellite.png",
        "western-estate-outlines.png",
        "western-estate-evidence.json"
      ],
      "auditStatus": "seated-outside-active-selection",
      "overlapActiveFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapId": null,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapFraction": 0,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapId": null,
      "seating": {
        "alreadySeated": true,
        "construction": "flat",
        "reliefM": 1.36,
        "terrainMinM": 134.96,
        "terrainMaxM": 136.32,
        "positionENU": [
          -3791.56,
          600.42,
          136.07
        ],
        "estimatedHeightM": 16,
        "heightSource": "estimated-from-footprint-area"
      },
      "caveat": "This is a substantial dense residential estate despite rural source tier; do not restore surrounding scattered houses wholesale. Repetition supports shared detail treatment, not invented identical measured heights. Small source roof features may be blurred.",
      "exclusionReason": null
    },
    {
      "id": "cad-4057",
      "locationWGS84": [
        110.431244925,
        28.40937735
      ],
      "areaSqm": 20669.8,
      "dimensionsM": [
        226.05,
        91.33
      ],
      "sourceTier": "urban",
      "classification": "industrial-roof",
      "decision": "exclude-residential-pilot",
      "roofMorphology": "Huge blue metal-sheet hall roofs with long central ridge and repeated transverse seams; surrounding loading/access strips. CAD outlines match the real industrial halls, not bogus giant GIS rectangles. cad-4060 is only partially inside this mosaic.",
      "imageryMatched": true,
      "imageryReviewed": true,
      "evidence": [
        "giant-industrial-satellite.png",
        "giant-industrial-outlines.png",
        "giant-industrial-evidence.json"
      ],
      "auditStatus": "terrain relief exceeds the allowed plinth; needs stepped construction",
      "overlapActiveFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapId": null,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapFraction": 0,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapId": null,
      "seating": {
        "alreadySeated": false,
        "reliefM": 5.56
      },
      "caveat": "Real missing industrial coverage, not missing residential slabs. Not already seated; DEM relief exceeds cap. Use a later purpose-built low-rise industrial model with independent terrain solution, not tall apartment floors.",
      "exclusionReason": "Wrong land-use/morphology for housing pilot and rejected DEM seating; do not relax the global plinth gate."
    },
    {
      "id": "cad-4058",
      "locationWGS84": [
        110.430591125,
        28.408456525000002
      ],
      "areaSqm": 20615.9,
      "dimensionsM": [
        226.04,
        91.12
      ],
      "sourceTier": "urban",
      "classification": "industrial-roof",
      "decision": "exclude-residential-pilot",
      "roofMorphology": "Huge blue metal-sheet hall roofs with long central ridge and repeated transverse seams; surrounding loading/access strips. CAD outlines match the real industrial halls, not bogus giant GIS rectangles. cad-4060 is only partially inside this mosaic.",
      "imageryMatched": true,
      "imageryReviewed": true,
      "evidence": [
        "giant-industrial-satellite.png",
        "giant-industrial-outlines.png",
        "giant-industrial-evidence.json"
      ],
      "auditStatus": "terrain relief exceeds the allowed plinth; needs stepped construction",
      "overlapActiveFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapId": null,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapFraction": 0,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapId": null,
      "seating": {
        "alreadySeated": false,
        "reliefM": 7.46
      },
      "caveat": "Real missing industrial coverage, not missing residential slabs. Not already seated; DEM relief exceeds cap. Use a later purpose-built low-rise industrial model with independent terrain solution, not tall apartment floors.",
      "exclusionReason": "Wrong land-use/morphology for housing pilot and rejected DEM seating; do not relax the global plinth gate."
    },
    {
      "id": "cad-4060",
      "locationWGS84": [
        110.42944365,
        28.406839274999996
      ],
      "areaSqm": 20669.7,
      "dimensionsM": [
        225.97,
        91.34
      ],
      "sourceTier": "urban",
      "classification": "industrial-roof",
      "decision": "exclude-residential-pilot",
      "roofMorphology": "Huge blue metal-sheet hall roofs with long central ridge and repeated transverse seams; surrounding loading/access strips. CAD outlines match the real industrial halls, not bogus giant GIS rectangles. cad-4060 is only partially inside this mosaic.",
      "imageryMatched": true,
      "imageryReviewed": true,
      "evidence": [
        "giant-industrial-satellite.png",
        "giant-industrial-outlines.png",
        "giant-industrial-evidence.json"
      ],
      "auditStatus": "terrain relief exceeds the allowed plinth; needs stepped construction",
      "overlapActiveFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapId": null,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapFraction": 0,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapId": null,
      "seating": {
        "alreadySeated": false,
        "reliefM": 8.81
      },
      "caveat": "Real missing industrial coverage, not missing residential slabs. Not already seated; DEM relief exceeds cap. Use a later purpose-built low-rise industrial model with independent terrain solution, not tall apartment floors.",
      "exclusionReason": "Wrong land-use/morphology for housing pilot and rejected DEM seating; do not relax the global plinth gate."
    },
    {
      "id": "cad-27730",
      "locationWGS84": [
        110.41231378965519,
        28.425087513793105
      ],
      "areaSqm": 17617.7,
      "dimensionsM": [
        141.88,
        190.75
      ],
      "sourceTier": "urban",
      "classification": "erroneous-compound-outline",
      "decision": "reject-wholesale-extrusion",
      "roofMorphology": "A giant irregular red boundary spans bare brown construction yard, separate bright roofs, courtyards and gaps along the river. No continuous roof matches its complete polygon.",
      "imageryMatched": false,
      "imageryReviewed": true,
      "evidence": [
        "giant-irregular-satellite.png",
        "giant-irregular-outlines.png",
        "giant-irregular-evidence.json"
      ],
      "auditStatus": "terrain relief exceeds the allowed plinth; needs stepped construction",
      "overlapActiveFraction": 0.0126,
      "candidateOverlapFraction": 0.063222,
      "candidateOverlapId": "cad-27626",
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapFraction": 0,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapId": null,
      "seating": {
        "alreadySeated": false,
        "reliefM": 39.19
      },
      "caveat": "Small true roofs inside this compound may merit later independent IDs; this parent outline is not one building. The 39.19m relief is a warning consistent with an invalid building-level envelope.",
      "exclusionReason": "Compound/erroneous GIS envelope rather than one roof; would fabricate a giant roof over open ground."
    },
    {
      "id": "cad-20346",
      "locationWGS84": [
        110.40031926666666,
        28.446832883333332
      ],
      "areaSqm": 433.5,
      "dimensionsM": [
        22.11,
        21.95
      ],
      "sourceTier": "rural",
      "classification": "duplicate-survey-outline",
      "decision": "exclude-pending-dedup",
      "roofMorphology": "The red square roof east of the residential bars has nested red survey outlines, not two separate structures. cad-20346 is entirely contained by cad-20347.",
      "imageryMatched": true,
      "imageryReviewed": true,
      "evidence": [
        "central-estate-satellite.png",
        "central-estate-outlines.png",
        "central-estate-evidence.json"
      ],
      "auditStatus": "seated-outside-active-selection",
      "overlapActiveFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapFraction": 1,
      "candidateOverlapId": "cad-20347",
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapFraction": 0,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapId": null,
      "seating": {
        "alreadySeated": true,
        "construction": "flat",
        "reliefM": 1.69,
        "terrainMinM": 111.37,
        "terrainMaxM": 113.06,
        "positionENU": [
          521.05,
          -794.31,
          112.81
        ],
        "estimatedHeightM": 16,
        "heightSource": "estimated-from-footprint-area"
      },
      "caveat": "The audit only compared candidates with active footprints, so zero active overlap does not establish candidate uniqueness. cad-20347 also overlaps its smaller outline by 76.85% of its own area; choose exactly one after roof/structure review.",
      "exclusionReason": "100% contained in cad-20347; adding both would duplicate one roof. Neither belongs in the selected residential bar pilot."
    },
    {
      "id": "cad-14165",
      "locationWGS84": [
        110.39475415,
        28.40224215
      ],
      "areaSqm": 1301.4,
      "dimensionsM": [
        45.76,
        28.54
      ],
      "sourceTier": "rural",
      "classification": "industrial-or-service-roof",
      "decision": "exclude-residential-pilot",
      "roofMorphology": "Broad green shed-like rectangular roof in a materials yard with nearby blue roofs, a narrow river and sparse red-roof houses; no repeated apartment row morphology.",
      "imageryMatched": true,
      "imageryReviewed": true,
      "evidence": [
        "southwest-edge-satellite.png",
        "southwest-edge-outlines.png",
        "southwest-edge-evidence.json"
      ],
      "auditStatus": "seated-outside-active-selection",
      "overlapActiveFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapFraction": 0.000007,
      "candidateOverlapId": "cad-14166",
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapFraction": 0,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapId": null,
      "seating": {
        "alreadySeated": true,
        "construction": "plinth",
        "reliefM": 3.18,
        "terrainMinM": 105.49,
        "terrainMaxM": 108.67,
        "positionENU": [
          -24.09,
          -5736.23,
          108.42
        ],
        "estimatedHeightM": 19.2,
        "heightSource": "estimated-from-footprint-area"
      },
      "caveat": "Already seated at 3.18m relief does not prove residential use or justify its estimated 19.2m height. Sparse vicinity is less compelling than the confirmed dense estates.",
      "exclusionReason": "Not compelling residential infill; broad service/industrial roof and uncertain height."
    },
    {
      "id": "cad-3544",
      "locationWGS84": [
        110.415807475,
        28.430365925
      ],
      "areaSqm": 1337.8,
      "dimensionsM": [
        60.41,
        22.5
      ],
      "sourceTier": "rural",
      "classification": "industrial-or-service-roof",
      "decision": "exclude-residential-pilot",
      "roofMorphology": "Single plain blue-gray elongated roof on east riverbank amid disturbed/material-storage ground; sports/campus buildings sit across the river, not in the same housing row.",
      "imageryMatched": true,
      "imageryReviewed": true,
      "evidence": [
        "east-dense-edge-satellite.png",
        "east-dense-edge-outlines.png",
        "east-dense-edge-evidence.json"
      ],
      "auditStatus": "seated-outside-active-selection",
      "overlapActiveFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapFraction": 0,
      "candidateOverlapId": null,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapFraction": 0,
      "otherNeighborhoodLayerOverlapId": null,
      "seating": {
        "alreadySeated": true,
        "construction": "flat",
        "reliefM": 1.78,
        "terrainMinM": 107.58,
        "terrainMaxM": 109.36,
        "positionENU": [
          2038.51,
          -2619.15,
          109.11
        ],
        "estimatedHeightM": 19.2,
        "heightSource": "estimated-from-footprint-area"
      },
      "caveat": "Roof and survey agree and existing relief is only 1.78m, but safe DEM seating is not evidence of apartment use; estimated 19.2m height is unsupported.",
      "exclusionReason": "Service/industrial-looking roof outside dense apartment rows; retain for separate use/height review."
    }
  ],
  "limits": [
    "Missing is relative to checked source/model footprint layers, not browser runtime confirmation.",
    "Imagery date, measured heights, precise floors, facade colors and windows remain unknown; keep all height/facade metadata explicitly estimated.",
    "Do not use unmasked satellite pixels as facade textures. Roof detail must preserve ridge/eave orientation; nearby shadows/trees/roads must not be projected onto roofs.",
    "No source plan, assets or config modified; recommendations only. Build/dev/server/browser debug intentionally skipped under AGENTS.md."
  ]
}