City-Lifeline-Cockpit/.scratch/cockpit-shell-panel-layout/verify/artifacts/t35/roof-imagery-quality/manual-review-gate.json

{
  "generatedAt": "2026-10-15",
  "decision": "manual-review-required",
  "thresholds": {
    "manualReviewDarkFraction": 0.3,
    "manualReviewSeamMeanRgbRms": 10.0,
    "manualReviewSeamP95RgbRms": 30.0
  },
  "roofCropRows": [
    {
      "id": "cad-25612",
      "darkFraction": 0.4018,
      "darkRisk": true,
      "sourceTileCount": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "cad-25467",
      "darkFraction": 0.4847,
      "darkRisk": true,
      "sourceTileCount": 2
    },
    {
      "id": "cad-25968",
      "darkFraction": 0.33973,
      "darkRisk": true,
      "sourceTileCount": 4
    },
    {
      "id": "cad-25957",
      "darkFraction": 0.35991,
      "darkRisk": true,
      "sourceTileCount": 2
    }
  ],
  "seamRows": [
    {
      "tileA": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422931/305369.png",
      "tileB": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422932/305369.png",
      "orientation": "east",
      "meanRgbRmsDelta": 9.52,
      "p95RgbRmsDelta": 24.41,
      "meanLumaDelta": 8.08,
      "manualReviewRisk": false
    },
    {
      "tileA": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422932/305369.png",
      "tileB": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422933/305369.png",
      "orientation": "east",
      "meanRgbRmsDelta": 7.42,
      "p95RgbRmsDelta": 19.32,
      "meanLumaDelta": 6.77,
      "manualReviewRisk": false
    },
    {
      "tileA": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422933/305369.png",
      "tileB": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422934/305369.png",
      "orientation": "east",
      "meanRgbRmsDelta": 9.57,
      "p95RgbRmsDelta": 24.3,
      "meanLumaDelta": 7.96,
      "manualReviewRisk": false
    },
    {
      "tileA": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422933/305370.png",
      "tileB": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422934/305370.png",
      "orientation": "east",
      "meanRgbRmsDelta": 11.98,
      "p95RgbRmsDelta": 32.85,
      "meanLumaDelta": 9.31,
      "manualReviewRisk": true
    },
    {
      "tileA": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422939/305370.png",
      "tileB": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422940/305370.png",
      "orientation": "east",
      "meanRgbRmsDelta": 13.19,
      "p95RgbRmsDelta": 31.2,
      "meanLumaDelta": 11.88,
      "manualReviewRisk": true
    },
    {
      "tileA": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422939/305371.png",
      "tileB": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422940/305371.png",
      "orientation": "east",
      "meanRgbRmsDelta": 6.47,
      "p95RgbRmsDelta": 14.2,
      "meanLumaDelta": 4.62,
      "manualReviewRisk": false
    },
    {
      "tileA": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422939/305372.png",
      "tileB": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422940/305372.png",
      "orientation": "east",
      "meanRgbRmsDelta": 8.48,
      "p95RgbRmsDelta": 21.13,
      "meanLumaDelta": 6.42,
      "manualReviewRisk": false
    },
    {
      "tileA": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422939/305373.png",
      "tileB": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422940/305373.png",
      "orientation": "east",
      "meanRgbRmsDelta": 8.74,
      "p95RgbRmsDelta": 21.02,
      "meanLumaDelta": 7.71,
      "manualReviewRisk": false
    },
    {
      "tileA": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422940/305370.png",
      "tileB": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422941/305370.png",
      "orientation": "east",
      "meanRgbRmsDelta": 6.65,
      "p95RgbRmsDelta": 15.43,
      "meanLumaDelta": 5.8,
      "manualReviewRisk": false
    },
    {
      "tileA": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422940/305371.png",
      "tileB": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422941/305371.png",
      "orientation": "east",
      "meanRgbRmsDelta": 8.02,
      "p95RgbRmsDelta": 23.07,
      "meanLumaDelta": 6.89,
      "manualReviewRisk": false
    },
    {
      "tileA": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422940/305372.png",
      "tileB": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422941/305372.png",
      "orientation": "east",
      "meanRgbRmsDelta": 7.85,
      "p95RgbRmsDelta": 18.4,
      "meanLumaDelta": 6.61,
      "manualReviewRisk": false
    },
    {
      "tileA": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422940/305373.png",
      "tileB": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422941/305373.png",
      "orientation": "east",
      "meanRgbRmsDelta": 7.16,
      "p95RgbRmsDelta": 17.03,
      "meanLumaDelta": 5.93,
      "manualReviewRisk": false
    },
    {
      "tileA": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422941/305370.png",
      "tileB": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422942/305370.png",
      "orientation": "east",
      "meanRgbRmsDelta": 7.33,
      "p95RgbRmsDelta": 22.85,
      "meanLumaDelta": 6.17,
      "manualReviewRisk": false
    },
    {
      "tileA": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422941/305371.png",
      "tileB": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422942/305371.png",
      "orientation": "east",
      "meanRgbRmsDelta": 6.57,
      "p95RgbRmsDelta": 18.88,
      "meanLumaDelta": 5.03,
      "manualReviewRisk": false
    },
    {
      "tileA": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422941/305372.png",
      "tileB": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422942/305372.png",
      "orientation": "east",
      "meanRgbRmsDelta": 5.65,
      "p95RgbRmsDelta": 12.81,
      "meanLumaDelta": 5.2,
      "manualReviewRisk": false
    },
    {
      "tileA": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422941/305373.png",
      "tileB": "D:/GIS/GIS/yuanlingPic3/19/422942/305373.png",
      "orientation": "east",
      "meanRgbRmsDelta": 7.68,
      "p95RgbRmsDelta": 20.5,
      "meanLumaDelta": 6.75,
      "manualReviewRisk": false
    }
  ],
  "automaticIntegrationAllowed": false,
  "reason": [
    "Statistics cover crop rectangles, not only roof UV pixels.",
    "Darkness can be shadow, roof material, occlusion or non-roof pixels.",
    "Tile edge deltas can cross different land cover.",
    "Only maintainer cockpit review can accept visual naturalness."
  ],
  "candidateUnchanged": true,
  "runtimeConfigChanged": false
}